Archive for the ‘Philosophy’ Category

The Divided Line

Saturday, February 28th, 2026

Plato’s analogy in Republic 509d-511e can be summarised as follows. Line segments A B C D Realm Intelligible (νοητος) (509d) Visible (ορατος) (509d) Objects Forms (511c) – considered in their relationship to the Good. The First Principle of things. (511a, b) The unassumed. Forms – NOT considered in their relationship to the Good Assumptions, mathematical postulates. (510c-511b) Living beings, plants, artificial things. (510a, e) Models, drawings ...

The Question of the ‘Legitimacy’ of Chinese Philosophy

Saturday, February 7th, 2026

Western philosophers – or philosophers working in the Western tradition – whatever their interest in Chinese systems of thought may be, do not draw upon them for insights, or adopt any of their ideas and concepts to augment the standard repertoire. In particular, where Chinese Philosophy is taught, it is ...

Feng Youlan’s Revisions

Sunday, January 2nd, 2022

Feng’s own philosophical positions were presented in a series of works beginning with the Xin Lixue (The New Study of Principles) which proposed a reform of the Lixue branch of Neoconfucianism associated with the names of the Song dynasty scholars Cheng Yi and Zhu Xi. (It is for that reason also called the Cheng-Zhu School.) His ...

Another Pointless Dialogue on Relativism About Truth

Tuesday, November 9th, 2021

The fourth effort A: All truths are relative B: Do you mean that all statements of fact are true for some and false for others? A: Yes, that’s what I mean. B: So a statement like ‘There is a hippopotamus in this room’ is true for some false for others? A: ...

Three Pointless Dialogues on Relativism about Truth

Monday, October 18th, 2021

I was reading and listening to some Steven Pinker articles and podcasts (for Quillette, I believe) talking about his new book on rationality, and one of the throwaway points he makes is that relativism about truth is a bad position. I don’t doubt that, but I’m not so sure that ...

L’incohérence de Bouddhisme

Thursday, October 14th, 2021

Le bouddhisme a la réputation d’être à la fois une religion et une philosophie : en fait, beaucoup de philosophes pensent que c’est une philosophie admirable. Il y en a cependant d’autres qui pensent que c’est un mélange des pseudo-profondeurs et d’incohérences. Par exemple, les bouddhistes disent que la fin ...

The Mystery of the Trinity Solved

Thursday, September 30th, 2021

Thus are God the Circle, God the Triangle, and God the Square all One God  

Daosheng On Buddha-Nature and Sudden Enlightenment

Wednesday, September 8th, 2021

The Buddha-nature (fóxìng – which translates Sanskrit tathAgatagarbha meaning the ‘matrix of the thus gone’ or buddhadhAtu meaning ‘the realm of the enlightened one’) was the subject of the second of Daosheng’s teachings that we will consider. The Buddha-nature was supposed to be that part of a being’s nature which ...

Sengzhao’s Arguments are Weak

Tuesday, August 10th, 2021

The doctrines and attitudes and practices that are thought of as typical of the Chan school arose early but gradually after Buddhism had been introduced to China. In particular, the early Chinese Buddhist scholars Sengzhao and Daosheng are considered to have laid the philosophical groundwork for the Chan school. So ...

Le Libre arbitre

Friday, July 9th, 2021

Chacun a le sentiment d’un libre arbitre même si il n’y croit pas. Chacun a le sentiment que c’est possible à faire autrement que ce qu’il fait ; il n’a qu’à choisir autrement que ce qu’il a choisi. Enfin, il a le sentiment que ce qu’il fait est la conséquence d’un ...