Previous LECTURES Next

 

 

 

(b)    D contains a sentence,

        "txy [[Qitx Ù Sjtx] ® [Qmt'x' Ù S0ty ® S0t'y Ù ... Ù Srty ® Srt'y]]

        There is Sq such that that sentence together with ds, [Succ], and [Diff] implies

        Qmes+1ep+1 Ù Sj1es+1ep1 Ù ... Ù Sjes+1ep Ù Sqes+1ep+1 Ù ... Ù Sjves+1epv

                        Ù "y[[y¹ep1 Ù ... Ù y¹ep Ù y¹ep+1 Ù ... Ù y¹epv] ® S0es+1y]

        which is an example of  ds+1.

(c)    Finally, D contains a sentence,

        "txy [[Qitx' Ù Sjtx'] ® [Qmt'x Ù S0ty ® S0t'y Ù ... Ù Srty ® Srt'y]]

        Again, there is Sq such that that sentence together with ds, [Succ], and [Diff] implies

        Qmes+1ep-1 Ù Sj1es+1ep1 Ù ... Ù Sjes+1ep-1 Ù Sqes+1ep Ù ... Ù Sjves+1epv

                        Ù "y[[y¹ep1 Ù ... Ù y¹ep-1 Ù y¹ep Ù ... Ù y¹epv] ® S0es+1y]

        which is an example of  ds+1.

==================================================================

    Therefore in all cases D |_ ds+1

    Therefore for any s > 0, if TM hasn't halted before s, D |_ ds

    So D |_ H

    So if TM(n) halts then D |_ H

    So D |_ H iff TM(n) halts

    So a solution to this problem is a solution to the halting problem

    So there is no solution to this decision problem.